As shipmasters shoulder responsibility, they should have final authority
30 December 2022
I read with interest your two reports 'Dutch safety board report challenges onboard authority' and 'Master should have authority during emergencies, New Zealand report finds' in the September/October edition of the Telegraph. It is perhaps interesting that that in both articles, while the investigation teams identify faults and errors by various parties, one advocates the master having overriding authority while the other states that the master should in some cases be overridden!
The Dutch conclusion is based on the assumption that the owner's advice is 'sound' and competent, but who is to judge whether any instruction is 'proper advice' – master or owner? The Dutch conclusion is not in my opinion well-formed or useful, and does not add value to the current situation where masters are obliged by simple mechanics of employment to follow the instructions of their owner, with the authority (and responsibility) to override any unsafe instruction.
Further, I would contend, based on personal experience, that owners are far more likely to propose unsafe or unrealistic courses of action than a master is to disregard 'proper advice', so the current system of checks and balances with 'instructions' from owners subject to the master's ultimate responsibility appears to remain superior to the Dutch proposal to vest all decision making in a single entity, which can only ever be considered effective based on the supposition that the advice or instruction from owner will always be correct. The Dutch conclusion appears to be incompatible with the ISM code, despite their acknowledging the master's 'final responsibility'.
Authority comes hand in hand with responsibility; one goes with the other. When anyone is obliged to follow an instruction, responsibility for the consequences also has to be taken by the party imposing the obligation. Only the individual with final responsibility can 'compel or oblige' and this in my opinion has to remain the master; no interpretation supports a scenario where the master can, or should, be able to be 'obliged or instructed to follow proper advice' – but we remain responsible regardless!
Captain Ruairidh MacAulay
More letters
In memory of Anthony (Tony) Fell
In memory of Anthony (Tony) Fell, a former Council member and a Union member since 1963 who was dedicated to furthering the development of radio officers.
SED should be extended to all those at sea for over six months a year
Given the changes in the operation of UK-flagged vessels, is it not time for the rules around claiming Seafarers' Earnings Deduction to be reviewed?
Scarlett Barnett-Smith: the maritime woman my mother wanted to be
I was very pleased to read in the last edition of the Telegraph about the success of recently-qualified officer Scarlett Barnett-Smith, whom I first met during her time at the Port of London Authority (PLA)